Really, the obsession that baseball writers have with these two.
I don't love Jayson Stark or anything, but he's usually a pretty reasonable guy. And actually, this article isn't over-the-top; it just repeats pretty much everything said about Rolen and the most bad ass shortstop-turned-German-wrestler around.
The highlights:
DUNEDIN, Fla. -- It's 786 miles (and one trip through the customs line) from Busch Stadium to the Rogers Centre. But Scott Rolen and David Eckstein don't measure that journey on their odometers.
What are they measuring it on? Their rulers? Their yardsticks?
Oh. Yeah. Probably their hearts. There's a lot of miles on old Eckstein's heart, seeing as he's motorvated every team he's ever been on to many wins.
No matter what you've read or heard, they never wanted to leave St. Louis, a place where they won together. A place where they were once showered with sea-of-red adoration together. But stuff happens. And it sure did happen to them.
Stuff does indeed happen, Jayson.
So now here they are, bound for the left side of the infield in a city north of the border. Here they are, about to become the first two infielders to transplant themselves into some other team's infield, within two years of starting at least 80 games for a World Series champion, since Bill White and Dick Groat went from the Cardinals to the Phillies in 1966.
Classic Stark.
Here they are, in their blue jerseys and blue caps -- not even a red sweatsock in sight. And it sure is fascinating that their new employers don't seem the least bit interested in the events that propelled them toward their awkward exits from St. Louis.
Not just a regular sock, ladies and gentlemen, but not even a red SWEAT sock is visible.
"Those two guys exemplify what we want to be," Blue Jays GM J.P. Ricciardi says. "That's why they're better fits for us. They're grinders, and they're dirtbags. Not that the guys we had before weren't. But that might be the one piece we were missing, from the standpoint of getting in there with the Red Sox and Yankees and just grinding it out from a day-to-day standpoint."
In nearly every profession in America, being called a "dirtbag" is a pretty bad thing. Yet, in some strange fashion, Ricciardi seems to be using it as an endearing term. Strange.
Do not fear, AL East fans. The Blue Jays are in the hands of a man who thinks that the difference between his team and the Red Sox/Yankees juggernauts is a lack of grinding it out on a day-to-day standpoint.
"Just the style of these two guys is something we needed," manager John Gibbons says. "It's not like either of them are such great players that everything comes so easy to them; they're cruisers. They both get down and dirty. And teams that win always have their share of those guys. I think we needed more of that."
What? I would think that if they had to work hard at certain things, they would be the opposite of cruisers! I think of "cruisers" as players who are :
1. So good at baseball they seem to cruise their way to ridiculous statistics every year with little effort (see Pujols, Albert and Rodriguez, Alex)
-or-
2. Very average at baseball but have the happy disposition that makes them just cruise through the clubhouse, because nobody is really jealous of their skills and their MVPs. (see Casey, Sean).
OK, maybe these guys are cruiser #2. Also, I like how John Gibbons gives them a nasty backhanded compliment: they're not so good ... they have to work hard!
Once, their old team said the same stuff about these two men. And it was all true. The fit was perfect, for both of them. They played on a 100-win team together in 2005. They played on a team that won the World Series in 2006. Eckstein was a World Series MVP. Rolen ripped off a 10-game postseason hitting streak.
I like how Stark uses these gaudy stats to describe how these two men had such successful careers. I like how they pleasantly obscure the fact that, in the last three seasons, those two gentlemen put together one combined season in which they OPS+'d over the league average.
That's how "stats" are "good". They can make a way for a pretty below average player seem like the best player in baseball.
There's a bunch of other crap about Rolen fighting with LaRussa and Eckstein being small. But that's the worst of it. I hope that my boss never tells me I'm not too good at my job, but he likes how I grind my way through the work day.
"Those two guys exemplify what we want to be," Blue Jays GM J.P. Ricciardi says. "That's why they're better fits for us. They're grinders, and they're dirtbags. Not that the guys we had before weren't. But that might be the one piece we were missing,"
ReplyDeleteSo his thought process goes like this:
- They are someting we want to be. (ie, they bring something we don't have)
- Not that the guys we had before weren't. (ie, it's not that we didn't have it already)
- But that might be the one piece we were missing. (ie, maybe we had it, maybe we didn't)
I thought Ricciardi was a Billy Beane disciple who understood that being a "grinder" and a "dirtbag" don't make up for being a lousy hitter and shitty shortstop. Now he sounds like Joe Morgan- "we didn't have it, but we actually did have it, but maybe we did or didn't have it."
If I was a Jays fan, I'd be worried that the team is in the hands of a GM who just made a move that he isn't sure filled a need that he isn't sure existed. Or one that thinks that ARod and Manny are so productive because they "grind it out day-to-day."
Ricciardi just lost whatever shred of his image as a "Moneyball" GM was left.
ReplyDeleteThis isn't the first time Ricciardi has called Rolen a dirtbag. Way back in January he said this:
ReplyDelete"We liked the grit and the grind," said Ricciardi describing Rolen. "If you look at the division we play in, Boston has a bunch of dirtbags and the Yankees have a bunch of dirtbags. We have some, but we need more ... guys who play the game the right way."
Seriously, can someone please explain to this guy that a "dirtbag" is not a good thing. I wonder if he himself has been called a dirtbag a ton of times and is merely confused.
Elijah Dukes and Delmon Young are dirtbags.
ReplyDeleteYou have to give credit to Jayson Stark for obviously doing some research while writing an article about the "talent" of Rolen and Eckstein: according to Google Maps, it really is 786 miles from Busch Stadium to the Skydome.
ReplyDelete"Don't move, DIRTBAG"..... (Cadet Laverne Hooks Police Academy)
ReplyDelete